Capability is often simplified to the direct skills needed to get a task done. However, being capable as part of an organisation is more than just a raw ability to execute one task after another. It also requires social and coordination skill across multiple teams and areas of expertise, and the developmental capacity to self-regulate and hold competing frames of reference in mind when deciding how to act.
In fact, there are three distinct axes of personal skill and maturity that need to be considered: Depth, Breadth, and Development, or DBD for short. Assessing staff against each axis can help to understand a person’s ability to robustly and flexibly apply their skills in novel situations without direct and explicit guidance through pre-existing organisational knowledge and processes.
Axis 1: Depth
Becoming a high-performing person with deep expertise in a particular skill domain is a matter of deliberate practice, not mere years of effort. Deliberate practice is the primary mechanism that moves a person along the experience pathway from novice to expert (Ericsson, Krampe & Tesch-Römer, 1993; Ericsson & Pool, 2016).
The six stages in the Dreyfus Skill Model (Rousse and Dreyfus, 2021) describe the progress of a typical person in gaining greater depth of expertise in relation to a particular skill:
Stage 1 – Novice. Novices depend on context-free rules and rigid step-by-step instructions. They expect to make mistakes, so are not yet emotionally invested in the outcomes they achieve and progress they make while learning through accumulated experience.
Stage 2 – Beginner. Beginners start noticing situational details and attempt to apply experience-based principles while still relying upon overt analysis and the general rules they have been taught. As they become more sophisticated and emotionally engaged in their work, beginners increasingly find their mistakes and errors frustrating.
Stage 3 – Competent. Competent performers gain an overall perspective of a problem and can set goals based on a conscious assessment of the situation. Performance remains structured and deliberate, but they feel stronger joy or regret about results and start learning to trust their intuition instead of clinging to predetermined rules and plans.
Stage 4 – Proficient. Proficient performers intuitively grasp a situation but still consciously decide how to respond, using explicit procedures to guide their choices. This enables greater adaptation in novel situations compared to earlier stages. As mastery continues to grow, they deepen their understanding of which intuited perspectives actually work in which circumstances and increasingly move away from pre-set approaches.
Stage 5 – Expert. Experts perceive and act as a single fluid process. They do not deliberate in normal circumstances, instead relying on their inventory of intuitive perspectives built from extensive experience. They reorient rapidly when conditions change and often cannot fully explain how they know what to do.
Stage 6 – Master. Some people – not all – may seek to move beyond expertise to mastery. Masters deliberately expand and refine their intuitive repertoire, sometimes inventing new ways of performing from scratch. Masters are happy to accept short-term drops in performance to explore overlooked possibilities and develop new forms of skilful action.
Axis 2: Breadth (I → T → π → M configuration)
Originating with Johnston (1978) and popularised by Guest (1991), the term “T-shaped skills” has become relatively common in capability discussions, referring to those people with strong technical depth, combined with the working knowledge necessary to work alongside others in adjacent disciplines. Later generalisations have broadened the “T-shaped” term into further arrangements that sought to provide a typology of experts:
I-shaped – a single area of technical depth, with minimal ability to participate outside that expertise
T-shaped – the classic technical expert with broad working knowledge
π-shaped – a person with two areas of technical depth
M-shaped (or comb shaped) – three or more areas of technical depth
The rapid evolution of skill requirements in jobs in recent years, as noted by Deming and Noray (2020), has seen a move away from traditional I-shaped and T-shaped employment opportunities. A single early specialisation depreciates in value rapidly, whereas people with multiple specialisations are more likely to be able to bridge disciplines effectively and adapt to new contexts.
A person’s “breadth” is more than just “being a good team player” or “working well with others”. It represents an ability to contribute meaningfully to adjacent work, for example by reading and understanding that discipline’s material, competently using the tools of its craft at an intermediate level, and collaborating jointly on deliverables (Brown, 2010). The ability to work, socialise, and coordinate across disciplines lowers the cost of trading tasks between teams and individuals, and makes hand-offs quick and efficient.
Axis 3: Development
Finally, the development axis represents a person’s ability to see perspectives and consider the needs of those beyond their own. Derived from the work of Kegan and Cook-Greuter (who termed the competency as someone’s “ego development”), this axis describes the systems of values and patterns of thinking which describe a person’s perception of and relation to the world around them.
Although the precise demarcations and descriptions remain under debate, the key evolutions can be represented as a five-level structure. Broadly, a person’s development level tends to increase along with age and experience, but some will remain more bound to their personal perspective than others. Each level is briefly described below:
Level 1 – Impulsive. The person is driven by their impulses and immediate needs, with little capacity for self-reflection or external perspective-taking. Others are seen mostly as helpers or obstacles.
Level 2 – Conformist. The person identifies with and seeks to conform to social norms and expectations of others. Relationships, roles, and community memberships become key to personal validation, with external validation and approval often necessary to feel secure.
Level 3 – Conscientious. The person is more considerate and responsible, and feels a sense of duty to others or to a higher cause. A strong sense of ethics and morality often develops, along with a strong sense of responsibility for their actions.
Level 4 – Autonomous. The person becomes more self-directed and independent, able to question authority and norms without seeking external approval. Their world is perceived in a more holistic and interconnected way.
Level 5 – Integrated. The person holds a nuanced perspective of themselves and others, able to hold multiple competing frames in mind at once. Attachment to personal views decreases with the fundamental recognition that each of our perspectives are self-created.
Those with higher levels of development have higher self-awareness, empathy, compassion, and greater appreciation for both the diversity and limitations of human values, ability, and reasoning. Murray (2017) groups these with attributes that are generally ascribed to wisdom such as big picture thinking, tolerance of uncertainty and ambiguity, and pragmatic, reality-based judgement.
However, it is proposed that these need to be separately accounted for in depth of expertise. It is entirely possible for people to have the ability to analytically assess a complex situation where they have no personal involvement, while being highly limited in their ability to accept and account for the perspectives of others when they are personally involved.
In summary:
Depth refers to a person’s skill and mastery in a domain-specific area.
Breadth is a person’s ability to work and collaborate in domains adjacent to their personal expertise.
Development refers to a person’s ability to evaluate and contextualise their choices in frames of reference beyond their own.
There is no one “best” score for these axes and higher is not always a better fit; in fact, sometimes they come into conflict. For example, there is some tension between a Level 3 “solid team player”, and the abilities needed for a person to succeed in roles where there are conflicting objectives and no stable rule book. A person with π-shaped skills at Level 4 and above may disproportionately succeed in leading complex teams and systems (for example, a principal engineer or chief architect) while being poorly suited for a business as usual (BAU) operational role.
References
Brown, T. (2010). Change by design (rev. ed.). Harper Business. (See also Brown’s earlier design-management writing on T-shaped people at IDEO.)
Cook-Greuter, S. R. (2004/2014). Making the case for a developmental perspective. Industrial and Commercial Training, 36(7), 275–281; and the MAP scoring manual (updated 2014).
Deming, D. J., & Noray, K. (2020). Earnings dynamics, changing job skills, and STEM careers. Quarterly Journal of Economics, 135(4), 1965–2005.
Ericsson, K. A., Krampe, R. T., & Tesch-Römer, C. (1993). The role of deliberate practice in the acquisition of expert performance. Psychological Review, 100(3), 363–406.
Ericsson, K. A., & Pool, R. (2016). Peak: Secrets from the new science of expertise. Houghton Mifflin Harcourt.
Guest, D. (1991). The hunt is on for the Renaissance man of computing. The Independent.
Johnston, D. L. (1978). Scientists become managers—The “T”-shaped man. IEEE Engineering Management Review, 6(3), 67–68.
Kegan, R. (1994). In over our heads: The mental demands of modern life. Harvard University Press.
Murray, T. (2017). Sentence completion assessments for ego development, meaning-making, and wisdom maturity, including STAGES. Integral Leadership Review, 17(2).
Rousse & Dreyfus. (2021). Revisiting the Six Stages of Skill Acquisition. In Mangiante, E. S., Peno, K., & Northup, J. (Eds.). Teaching and learning for adult skill acquisition: applying the Dreyfus and Dreyfus model in different fields. IAP.

